in terms of "rights issues" How does this feature fit with videos that censor comments by "comment pending approval"?...Using this tool limits freedom of type/print yet the very backbone of Youtube is freedom of expression
ContentID has still got some frauds - I noticed that a lot of karaoke video, where the video maker sung were deleted due to "copyright" but even worse were the copyright claims of IGN against gamers and other gaming reviewers of Epic Mickey laterly. A human beeing would see, that the content is generated by the channel maker, but since parts of a game are very simmilar (e.g. cutscenes) the ContentID-bots "think" it is material of a YouTube-partner. Sadly industrial YouTube-partners are prefered and for "normal" users it is almost impossible to reach a responsable human beeing via the support.
That's great. What is not clear is how amateur, not for profit YouTube contributors can use portions copyrighted material in their videos for which the copyright holder has claims and continue to use it and allow the owner of the copyright to monetize it. If you read your copyright policy, I believe it is very strict and no one should upload copyrighted material. But I see it all the time, Very confusing,
We all hate it, instead of automatic "We can do whatever we want" from the record label (I'm talking about WMG & Sony) we should be given a choice to Accept the choice Dispute The choice (Misidentification, Fair Use etc.) or Work It Out with record label
Pity also it doesn't protect the little guy who uploads original content only to have it stolen right off youtube's site then reposted, many times garnering more hits on the stolen repost than those for which the rightful owner was credited.
The way this post is tell sounds like "great news" but it´s shit...a lot of people used Youtube to show any kind of talent they got,just for fun or to entertain others...without any kind of money shit.I have an account because i love making vids just for pure fun and i think Youtube is going down the hill with this shitty news...Good luck to you!!! *oh yeah i´m using my sarcasm*
Just shows how Google and YouTube will do anything as long as it helps the stock holders, even if it hurts the people that made it so popular to start - the average user.
So obviously....its all about the $ This article and any I read from YT never speak of the Fair Use Act, none speak of (their) "threats of suspending my account due to copyright infringements"? ...Yet now I see many folks using copyrighted music, and it is OK ?....(Now YT is allowing some (??) to use music with adds)
And yet its very unclear when and who's music can I use. The YT company writes articles like this telling us all how great their services are becoming ...yet I read all the comments and see that the topic and concern of this matter is not being addressed at all by YT (??).....
They brag about all the $ copyrighters can now make....but what about folks who are not here to "sell" or "make money" ..... we are not even being addressed.
Can I use copyrighted material like in how this article brags YT is allowing? ...or is WMG or SONY or someone from YT trolling for Content ID matches. I mean what is it? I have been told one more time and my account will be suspended, but can I get clarity on this ..... obviously not. (its all about the $)
I have false claims being made on some of my videos where third parties are claiming they own the music on my videos yet clearly are not. One such claim was from a organization called SME. Clearly, they are miss using the system and ripping me off. Very unhappy that the dispute system hasn't worked for me as the organization has counter claimed, basically lied back to me.
This system is prone to liars to miss use the system.
AlanT you are correct. The dispute systm is essentially non existant and plays directlyagainst original music creators. It's better to simply go elsehere with the content until youtube fixes the dispute process.
Follow
Pity it doesn't take into account transformative use and the like.
ReplyDeletein terms of "rights issues" How does this feature fit with videos that censor comments by "comment pending approval"?...Using this tool limits freedom of type/print yet the very backbone of Youtube is freedom of expression
ReplyDeleteLocking down freedom and the internet, one video at a time, go Google!
ReplyDeleteSo now that its three years old when are you letting more people in? I applied on June 21, 2010 and am still waiting :(
ReplyDeleteContent ID is depressing because it doesn't give us any rights.
ReplyDeleteLove this service, it allows companies to monetize videos that users have created using infringing material, without having the material removed!
ReplyDeleteYay, Vevo! (sarcasm)
ReplyDeleteTOO BAD WMG IS EXPLOITING THIS!
ReplyDeleteYou seem to write this like it's a good thing...
ReplyDeletewat about fair use? the computer should be made to detect that automatically.
ReplyDeleteContentID has still got some frauds - I noticed that a lot of karaoke video, where the video maker sung were deleted due to "copyright" but even worse were the copyright claims of IGN against gamers and other gaming reviewers of Epic Mickey laterly. A human beeing would see, that the content is generated by the channel maker, but since parts of a game are very simmilar (e.g. cutscenes) the ContentID-bots "think" it is material of a YouTube-partner. Sadly industrial YouTube-partners are prefered and for "normal" users it is almost impossible to reach a responsable human beeing via the support.
ReplyDeleteThat's great. What is not clear is how amateur, not for profit YouTube contributors can use portions copyrighted material in their videos for which the copyright holder has claims and continue to use it and allow the owner of the copyright to monetize it. If you read your copyright policy, I believe it is very strict and no one should upload copyrighted material. But I see it all the time, Very confusing,
ReplyDeleteEvery time I get a content match it scares the crap out of me and I delete the video. I have one strike against me and can't afford to get any more.
ReplyDeleteCensorship win
ReplyDelete"Hey, you wanna post a Guitar Hero/Rock Band video?"
ReplyDelete"No way. I'm not gonna risk having my account suspended because of the content ID system."
Surprise surprise, content ID and money.
ReplyDeleteWe all hate it, instead of automatic "We can do whatever we want" from the record label (I'm talking about WMG & Sony) we should be given a choice to Accept the choice
ReplyDeleteDispute The choice
(Misidentification, Fair Use etc.)
or Work It Out with record label
Pity also it doesn't protect the little guy who uploads original content only to have it stolen right off youtube's site then reposted, many times garnering more hits on the stolen repost than those for which the rightful owner was credited.
ReplyDeleteAnd from then on, countless YouTubers would yell at WMG for muting their audio (myself included).
ReplyDelete3 years of this process getting abused and illegally used by big corporations. Way to go youtube.......
ReplyDeleteYeah this system is pretty much a fail. If my video gets block that means somebody's gonna die.
ReplyDeleteand this is why facebook needs a dislike button.
ReplyDeleteI think this needs to be changed to 3 years since youtube died. Youtube died when they started muting music, and AMVs on youtube got blocked too.
ReplyDeleteThe System that brought the companies that fuck our **** turns 3. Yaaaay.
ReplyDeleteThe way this post is tell sounds like "great news" but it´s shit...a lot of people used Youtube to show any kind of talent they got,just for fun or to entertain others...without any kind of money shit.I have an account because i love making vids just for pure fun and i think Youtube is going down the hill with this shitty news...Good luck to you!!! *oh yeah i´m using my sarcasm*
ReplyDeleteJust shows how Google and YouTube will do anything as long as it helps the stock holders, even if it hurts the people that made it so popular to start - the average user.
ReplyDeleteYouTube are you reading these comments? NO ONE LIKES CONTENT ID!!! So to make your customers that much happier, I suggest you GET RID OF CONTENT ID!!!
ReplyDeleteOnly YouTube could see this as something worth celebrating. Shows how totally out of touch you are with your users.
ReplyDeleteSo obviously....its all about the $
ReplyDeleteThis article and any I read from YT never speak of the Fair Use Act, none speak of (their) "threats of suspending my account due to copyright infringements"? ...Yet now I see many folks using copyrighted music, and it is OK ?....(Now YT is allowing some (??) to use music with adds)
And yet its very unclear when and who's music can I use. The YT company writes articles like this telling us all how great their services are becoming ...yet I read all the comments and see that the topic and concern of this matter is not being addressed at all by YT (??).....
They brag about all the $ copyrighters can now make....but what about folks who are not here to "sell" or "make money" ..... we are not even being addressed.
Can I use copyrighted material like in how this article brags YT is allowing? ...or is WMG or SONY or someone from YT trolling for Content ID matches. I mean what is it? I have been told one more time and my account will be suspended, but can I get clarity on this ..... obviously not. (its all about the $)
Awful system at the moment for me.
ReplyDeleteI have false claims being made on some of my videos where third parties are claiming they own the music on my videos yet clearly are not. One such claim was from a organization called SME. Clearly, they are miss using the system and ripping me off. Very unhappy that the dispute system hasn't worked for me as the organization has counter claimed, basically lied back to me.
This system is prone to liars to miss use the system.
We need it to be improved.
AlanT you are correct. The dispute systm is essentially non existant and plays directlyagainst original music creators. It's better to simply go elsehere with the content until youtube fixes the dispute process.
ReplyDelete