Can you add a time limit of say, five minutes before you can't delete/edit your comment, because there are a lot of debates that go on and then people will say "you said this" then that person may just delete their comment.
big fucking deal googletube..what you really need to do is REMOVE the option to mark peoples comments as spam on videos.that is easily abused and people who make non spam comments are marked as spam.it is up to the person who owns the video to make that decision you stupid moronic cocksucking whores:)now and that also happens on profile comments.
@aallalallalalaaa I have to agree, I got my OWN comments on my profile marked as spam, they just deleted my comment, not only that, the comment count stayed the same, so freaking annoying.
Thank you for adding this feature. This will encourage people to interact online in a manner more in line with personal preference.
I really like the spam feature. I have found that when others do not like a comment and find it offensive, they make a choice that is considerate of the next person who will see that page. I love reading positive feedback, I personally appreciate when people mark as spam something that I do not need to see.
Some of these people who comment on this blog are just idiots. They hate on EVERYTHING YouTube does. But this is a really good idea, I've been waiting for this for a while. I misspell a lot.. lol, thank you, YouTube!!!
this is off topic, but would like to point out that as a film student if I'm not mistaken amateur videos such as user creations on YouTube are protected from copyright laws. As there is no profit intent the videos supply word of mouth advertising.
Now you could delete this post which is great, but I just wanted to point out that a great deal of your users will be leaving your community if you feel your "Disable Audio" feature is necessary.
I think the original comment should be displayed to video owners still instead of the current message that makes you wonder what was said and by whom (unless you've already got it in an E-mail notice).
Really good, it also improves privacy on the site. It should also be avaible for channel comments. And if there was a way to see all the comments you've made that would be nice too.
Once again I'm still waiting for a way to report people for posting hateful and troll-like comments on videos for their own personal lulz. Do something about it.
Hey YOutube, I have been here for 3 years and this is the first feature that I dont personally agree with. When it comes to slander or hateful purposes, the ability to be unaccountable is now removed. I imagine people will take advantage of this feature but I can only try and be positive about it. ~Raven
Please don't put a time limit, or at least one as short as five minutes, for the opportunity to delete comments. I sometimes find typos and factual errors in my comments (I do a lot of commenting on the subject of 1950s-early 1980s popular music), but sometimes it's a month or more after I posted them.
|Once again I'm still waiting for a way to report people for posting hateful and troll-like comments on videos for their own personal lulz. Do something about it.
I completely and totally agree with this. That is a feature that really needs to be added. There are so many videos that are on positive topics that people just kill with their hateful comments. Please add it. For the good of the community.
Without some kind of time limit, I cannot agree with this feature. I think that users should not have the ability to remove comments once that comment has been replied to.
This "feature" gives users the ability to be unaccountable for anything they say. I know that I for one will quote and re-post any comments that I receive, identifying the original poster.
Finally! I was so sick of being accountable for the things that I say in YouTube comments. Now when I get caught lying about something I can re-write history and make it look like it never happened! This is going to make being a dishonest little weasel so much easier. Thanks YouTube!
Youtube seriously this is a horrible idea the way its currently setup. Especially on videos where heavy debate occurs. It is extremely annoying to see "comment deleted by author" in the middle of a argument thread. The whole re-write history thing is right. You all need to set a time limit on deleting a comment like DIGG and other sights do. Please take this into consideration. I've already seen one persons video where every other comment is deleted by author its just annoying.
Thanks for your time and consideration of this matter. Also do not allow editing. That allows for a true re-write of history in a debate thread.
I find h8uall66's comment on this entirely correct: "Finally! I was so sick of being accountable for the things that I say in YouTube comments. Now when I get caught lying about something I can re-write history and make it look like it never happened! This is going to make being a dishonest little weasel so much easier. Thanks YouTube! " I have nothing more to add.
This is destructive to your site. Please remove this feature as soon as possible. I like to communicate and debate on friendly terms but since the record of conversation can be changed and altered at will, it is worthless to debate.
I agree with brewhahh. This idea/feature is ill advised, and has not been thought thru. IMO, someone can post something inflamatory then after others reply? Delete it and make repliers look like they're nuts. It will also interrupt the flow of conversation in the comments section.
I don't think this is a good idea because it gets really confusing when people delete their own comments. Sometimes, you don't even know what the comment was!
Plus, YouTube is a place where people can share ideas and thoughts. People shouldn't be allowed to remove their comments.
If you're going to keep the self-comment removing, at least don't allow users to edit their comments. That would be very confusing!
Let's say someone said something good at first. And then, a person replies by saying, "Yes, I agree with you." But then, the person might just go back and edit their comment to something that is completely opposite. I hope you get my point. Don't allow self-editing!
a edit option with a time limit would have been way better, but instead this idea would break the flow of a debate. just a couple of minutes is enough for someone to fix their typos or change and idea.
"or you simply said something you wish you could take back - now you can remove your commentary at any time." I think its better if someone does something like that that person should reply his/her own post with something like "my previous comment does not represent my current opinion" or something like that.
Great feature, spammers have been using it a lot so they can wipe clean the first couple of pages of comments, and now you can't even report them for spamming. With the comment system being broken (I'm talking about comments past page two not being in chronological order, a problem m.youtube.com doesn't seem to have for some odd reason) you can't keep track of the discussion anymore.
I don't really see this feature as really necessary if people actually bothered to READ what they are planning to post instead of simply typing it all and clicking 'Post Comment' so hastily.It's actually making things alot harder.
Do yourself a favor and just take the time to read what you're about to post instead of clicking the 'Post Comment' button hastily as if you're about to die in 30 seconds.
I like it because even though I read my comments before I post, I still make spelling errors that end up messing up the whole comment. . Is it necessary to have the comment block remain and the Username present? It looks very messy like that and takes up comment space. I wouldn't mind seeing something completely removed and have it be removed, not "This comment has been deleted" Since that is something I don't need to know.
Yeah cool guys, thanks, I was just thinking this morning on the way to work (yeah, I know, where is my life), "I wish I could remove my comment on YouTube".
I keep making these stupid mistakes when I write and always wanted to correct them. Great!
What next: I really think you should consider HD video or higher quality.
Also, would love to see the site with a nice Adobe-style grey background to the site!
stupid idea. you should have it where the person who owns the channel decide if they want the option of allowing people to remove their comments. this will totally ruin the flow of debate.
This is an abomination. Now, people can remove comments that are against their point of views. Think of the Scientologists and conservatives deleting comments made by innocent people just trying to express themselves.
The Youtube comment boxes allow people to debate, and you just ruined everything
"Now, people can remove comments that are against their point of views." What? Is something wrong with you? You can only delete YOUR OWN comments. (Also, nice job lumping Scientologists and conservatives together).
I'm sorry, this feature is pointless. It totally debases intelligent discourse, and has lowered the standard level of accountability on chained discussions. You could have spent the time and effort developing an OPTIONAL feature (toggled by the video submitter) to allow users to edit/delete/lock comments. I could code that for a site in a couple hours.... this is terribly lazy web software development and awful site-to-end-user communication.
You could have even developed a "Block" feature, that allows video submitters to build a list of users that are blocked from commenting on a specific video.
Or even an "ignore" feature, user(A) can comment rudely, but user(B) can gleefully ignore user(A) with ease. Each user has a list of ignored users. Comments from ignored users are hidden from the specific user that ignores them (or if added to a video's ignore list, not visible to any user). Thus, accountability and continuity of a dialog are preserved... youtube will be forward-thinking and ad-friendly.
I really like this new feature, but I have recently noticed that you guys have removed another one: the ability to show comments with many negative votes. Now you may think that this is a harmless improvement, but I personally enjoy reading some of these. If you could bring back this feature (as well as, if not ESPECIALLY--the center frame thumbnails algorithm) I would be very grateful! Thank you for reading.
AYO WHO TAUGHT U HOW TO DO DIS SHIT! DA DANCE OLD IS H3LL U R3ALLY N33D TA GO FIND DA NIGGA DAT TOLD U IT WAS NEW N FUCC HIM UP DO ME DAT FAVA BRA, ALSO U MAD3 UR SELF LOOK DUMB 4 LISTENING TO DA NIGGA BUT GO TO THIS http://vids.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=vids.individual&videoid=7315795&searchid=c275c5ad-d2f7-44fb-9fe8-c1c513e20a95 N LOOK AT DA DAT3 DO DAT 4 M3 W3 B33N DOIN THIS!!!
O Y3A L3ARN SOM3 SHIT FROM KIDS TOO LOL YOU NIGGAS BUGG3D OUT
I really can't believe this site and it's inane error messages. I c/p tags in my videos and I get this error message that I need at least one tag. If you think I'm going to type them in every time...you are crazy!
Relax people, YouTube is just bouncing the old-skool way. Where would the bible be without this kind of system xD... Oh, and great job with completely disabling the ability to view of spam messages. So are you guys gonna remove another portion of YT's entertainment and / or expression possibility in the near future?
More than 1.2 hectares,850 - 900k negotiable.Farm planted consist mainly of 300 trees of lansones that can harvest yearly,season of september - october, also includes coconut, macapuno and santol trees, harvest on it's peak season..for more inquiries..
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tQIC2KyxolU plz delete my can from your site as some one wants to abuse me in worng way my e mail id is jatt_friendfinder9#yahoo.co.in
my user name at you tube is gurpreetkahlon plz delete my cam as soon as u receive this my link is http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tQIC2KyxolU some one put my cam in bad sense my yahoo id is jatt_friendfinder9@yahoo.co.in
as some one put my cam on you tube in wrong sense plz remove it as soon as you can my email id is jatt_friendfinder9@yahoo.co.in and gurpreetsingh.kahlon@yahoo.co.in kindly reply me soon for it
Hi there , someone have posted my video,i have not posted, in the video its me, so can you delete the video and other people do not watch, please remove it. the link of te video is: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o7tgf-NdiwM
And how are we supposed to find every comment we made thru the years ??? i can't search for every single one of them ! is there a list somewhere in my profile ??
incantare666, google your youtube screen name just the way you type it when signing on to youtube then hit search, everything and anything you've ever commented on will come up
I just wish you guys could do the same for channel comments, and when you delete a comment on a video, I wish it never said "Comment Removed by author" and it could just be gone forever.
That tool is really helpful, although I agree with SporeDotCam. It's really, really annoying when you want to delete one of your comments and it says "Comment removed by author". Why not just introduce a tool that deletes the comments completely? You don't have to be able to "re-publish" your comments.. If that would be the case for anyone, they could just rewrite it. But besides that, thanks for a great site :)
No, Th3Agitator, i've just checked it out: You don't find EVERY comment you've ever made on yt via google, just some of them. Anyway, fishing for them by yourself using a search engine? You must be kidding! There definetely should be a PROPER function WITHIN youtube.
That would be such a big improvement especially for a high percentage typo error like me. But my "Enter" finger is always to quick to submit my posting. And "walla" too late if I can't delete or change my just posted comment.
Follow
Sweet! Gotta' start deleting all my comments... LOL
ReplyDelete-Blade Genexis
Thanks You Tube this is great!
ReplyDeleteweee
ReplyDeleteAwesome........however I wonder if one could cope up with the amount of comment lol
ReplyDeleteGood! So glad it's finally here.
ReplyDeletebuhleeted.
ReplyDeleteCan you add a time limit of say, five minutes before you can't delete/edit your comment, because there are a lot of debates that go on and then people will say "you said this" then that person may just delete their comment.
ReplyDeletePlease, add a time feature.
BTW, it's not THAT hard to add a time feature, it's about one line of code.
ReplyDeletean AJAX edit option would be good too.
>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala>lala
ReplyDeletebig fucking deal googletube..what you really need to do is REMOVE the option to mark peoples comments as spam on videos.that is easily abused and people who make non spam comments are marked as spam.it is up to the person who owns the video to make that decision you stupid moronic cocksucking whores:)now and that also happens on profile comments.
ReplyDeleteGood thing too do on YT :)
ReplyDelete@aallalallalalaaa I have to agree, I got my OWN comments on my profile marked as spam, they just deleted my comment, not only that, the comment count stayed the same, so freaking annoying.
ReplyDeleteThank you for adding this feature. This will encourage people to interact online in a manner more in line with personal preference.
ReplyDeleteI really like the spam feature. I have found that when others do not like a comment and find it offensive, they make a choice that is considerate of the next person who will see that page. I love reading positive feedback, I personally appreciate when people mark as spam something that I do not need to see.
Thank you for all your work!
Good ideas!
ReplyDeleteoh thank god
ReplyDeletei'm an idiot sometimes
thank you i am new at this i need all the help i can get
ReplyDeleteyay...no more getting in trouble with my comments :)
ReplyDeleteYou could always delete your comments..
ReplyDeletenjn
ReplyDeleteI'm sure I'll be using this feature a lot!!!
ReplyDeleteNOOOOO
ReplyDeleteWhy add a feature that adds complete plasticity to the commenting system??
Imagine a history that is ever-changing by the will of others... not an idea I would like to see commenced...
Some of these people who comment on this blog are just idiots. They hate on EVERYTHING YouTube does.
ReplyDeleteBut this is a really good idea, I've been waiting for this for a while. I misspell a lot.. lol, thank you, YouTube!!!
Nice if there was a way to find old comments too.
ReplyDeleteEG www.myvideocomments.com - if it would work
This is stupid.
ReplyDeleteI like that new feature. Unfortunately it only works in video comments, and I'd like it to also work in users channel comments as well.
ReplyDeletetest
ReplyDeletethis is off topic, but would like to point out that as a film student if I'm not mistaken amateur videos such as user creations on YouTube are protected from copyright laws. As there is no profit intent the videos supply word of mouth advertising.
ReplyDeleteNow you could delete this post which is great, but I just wanted to point out that a great deal of your users will be leaving your community if you feel your "Disable Audio" feature is necessary.
Just wanted to point this out.
nice idea
ReplyDeletebut will the person still recieve a message stating the message you sent? Cause that's the embarrising part...
ReplyDeleteNext, I want YouTube users to be able to delete spam comments.
ReplyDeletethank god!
ReplyDeletehow bout the channel comments? can you delete them?
ReplyDeleteI think the original comment should be displayed to video owners still instead of the current message that makes you wonder what was said and by whom (unless you've already got it in an E-mail notice).
ReplyDeletewow
ReplyDeletethe youtube team has actually done something useful for once.
makes a change;
try to continue not screwing up
Really nice.
ReplyDeleteIt should also be avaible for profile comments.
Really good, it also improves privacy on the site. It should also be avaible for channel comments. And if there was a way to see all the comments you've made that would be nice too.
ReplyDeleteAt Last!!!
ReplyDeleteOnce again I'm still waiting for a way to report people for posting hateful and troll-like comments on videos for their own personal lulz. Do something about it.
ReplyDeleteNow nobody will ever have to look like a fool again by claiming to be the first comment on a video when someone else has beat them to it.
ReplyDeletewhat about the audio preview feature? is it gone?
ReplyDeleteGreat feature. much needed! Thanks Yourtube team!
ReplyDeleteha ha ha pretty cool i guess especially for those really awkward times!
ReplyDeletefuck you youtube.you just delete my fucking video. fucking idiots.
ReplyDeleteHOLY CRAP. THE YOUTUBE TEAM ACTUALLY DID SOMETHING GOOD.
ReplyDeleteNOW MAKE IT SO THAT WE CAN UPLOAD VIDEOS MORE THAN 10 MINUTES AGAIN.
I think this is a great idea. I hate to leave curse words I have made during the past 2 years up. I am going to delete them!
ReplyDeleteThe test FAILED miserable!
ReplyDeleteLOL
THIS IS A TEST to see if I can delete this comment.
ReplyDeleteTHIS IS A TEST!
I TAGGED u before I die.....
I found this wonderful web site.
"before I die I"
I LOVE IT!
I have two "wishes" on the list.
check me out i have some videos i kno u will like subscribe too
ReplyDeletetest
ReplyDeletetest=fail
ReplyDeleteyay
ReplyDeletetest
ReplyDelete?
ReplyDeleteNice feature
ReplyDeleteYah
ReplyDeleteI thinks a great feature but I can't delete my comment here lol
ReplyDeletelawl
ReplyDeleteGreat idea!
ReplyDeletethis is the only good thing youtube has done in years
ReplyDeleteLove and equality for all/ Amor y igualdad para todos
ReplyDeleteQuadunit404 (1 hour ago)
ReplyDeleteHOLY CRAP. THE YOUTUBE TEAM ACTUALLY DID SOMETHING GOOD. NOW MAKE IT SO THAT WE CAN UPLOAD VIDEOS MORE THAN 10 MINUTES AGAIN.
it should be for everyone so i agree with you
good idea
ReplyDeleteJust so you know, it doesn't always work. Needs more work, to get rid of the glitches.
ReplyDeleteOfftopic, but:
ReplyDelete[...]This video is no longer available due to a copyright claim by Warner Music Group Germany.[...]
YUTUBE U ARE KILLING YOURSELVES! THANK YOU GOOGLE!!!
Hey YOutube, I have been here for 3 years and this is the first feature that I dont personally agree with. When it comes to slander or hateful purposes, the ability to be unaccountable is now removed. I imagine people will take advantage of this feature but I can only try and be positive about it. ~Raven
ReplyDeleteFinally!!! What take ya guys so damn long
ReplyDeletenope, apparently I can't :0)
ReplyDeletewonder if I can remove this comment :)
ReplyDeleteI LOVE YOU
ReplyDeletegood idea
ReplyDeletePlease don't put a time limit, or at least one as short as five minutes, for the opportunity to delete comments. I sometimes find typos and factual errors in my comments (I do a lot of commenting on the subject of 1950s-early 1980s popular music), but sometimes it's a month or more after I posted them.
ReplyDeleteMary-kate and Ashley Olsen
ReplyDeleteMary-kate and Ashley Olsen
Mary-kate and Ashley Olsen
it wrks
awesome, i'm going to try it out!!!
ReplyDeletecool
ReplyDelete|Once again I'm still waiting for a way to report people for posting hateful and troll-like comments on videos for their own personal lulz. Do something about it.
ReplyDeleteI completely and totally agree with this. That is a feature that really needs to be added. There are so many videos that are on positive topics that people just kill with their hateful comments. Please add it. For the good of the community.
fuck yes
ReplyDeleteyou did something good
i am happy
ok
ReplyDeletetest
ReplyDeleteWithout some kind of time limit, I cannot agree with this feature. I think that users should not have the ability to remove comments once that comment has been replied to.
ReplyDeleteThis "feature" gives users the ability to be unaccountable for anything they say. I know that I for one will quote and re-post any comments that I receive, identifying the original poster.
Now that's a VERY VERY VERY good idea.
ReplyDeleteI am a comment editting whore (comments never seem to be good enough) and now my whorism can be satisfied.
Finally!!!
ReplyDeletenext thing to make us happy is if you can remove widescreen!!!
Nice
ReplyDeletevery nice :)
ReplyDeletesweet
ReplyDeleteIts nice but I can't find a tutorial on this.
ReplyDeleteCool, finally, YouTube listens to something we ask.
ReplyDeleteBut in all seriousness, how about adding the ability to edit a comment we posted?
Awesome I'm so fat fingered I'm always mispelling things and think god how stupid do i look now.
ReplyDeleteWonderful update!! :)
ReplyDeleteawesomeness
ReplyDeleteGood upgrade. It would also be nice to also edit a comment without deleting.
ReplyDeleteFinally! I was so sick of being accountable for the things that I say in YouTube comments. Now when I get caught lying about something I can re-write history and make it look like it never happened! This is going to make being a dishonest little weasel so much easier. Thanks YouTube!
ReplyDeleteYeah 0 accountability for the empty assertions and so forth anyone can make.
ReplyDeleteThis opens an entire new field of deception on YouTube.
hmm i wonder if i can delete this one
ReplyDeleteA horrible feature that will be abused by tons of people. A simple 2-minute edit time limit would've done the trick, if it really were necessary.
ReplyDeleteYoutube seriously this is a horrible idea the way its currently setup. Especially on videos where heavy debate occurs. It is extremely annoying to see "comment deleted by author" in the middle of a argument thread. The whole re-write history thing is right. You all need to set a time limit on deleting a comment like DIGG and other sights do. Please take this into consideration. I've already seen one persons video where every other comment is deleted by author its just annoying.
ReplyDeleteThanks for your time and consideration of this matter. Also do not allow editing. That allows for a true re-write of history in a debate thread.
I find h8uall66's comment on this entirely correct:
ReplyDelete"Finally! I was so sick of being accountable for the things that I say in YouTube comments. Now when I get caught lying about something I can re-write history and make it look like it never happened! This is going to make being a dishonest little weasel so much easier. Thanks YouTube! "
I have nothing more to add.
This "feature" is brutal -- this renders all debate and conversation on YouTube useless -- accountability is gone.
ReplyDeleteThis is destructive to your site. Please remove this feature as soon as possible. I like to communicate and debate on friendly terms but since the record of conversation can be changed and altered at will, it is worthless to debate.
ReplyDelete....
ReplyDeleteReal bad idea, no point in commenting on someone's stupidity anymore, because when you do they delete the evidence. /clap youtube.
ReplyDeleteI agree with brewhahh. This idea/feature is ill advised, and has not been thought thru. IMO, someone can post something inflamatory then after others reply? Delete it and make repliers look like they're nuts. It will also interrupt the flow of conversation in the comments section.
ReplyDeleteFrank
Fuck you, Youtube.
ReplyDeleteBad idea is bad.
ReplyDeletevery nice thanks
ReplyDeleteWell....I guess these comments tell you that this feature will be gone quickly. And rightfully so, cuz it blows. "Mister Pink"
ReplyDeleteAllow self-editing of comments. For the lulz.
ReplyDeleteok
ReplyDeletethis feature is really a bad idea. it removes accountability. how are we supposed to quote what someone else said when the quote can be removed?
ReplyDeleteeither completely remove this feature or make it optional for the creator of the video (with the default preferably being non-removable comments).
thank you.
did anyone else notice that the people who think that this is a good feature are the same morons who seem like they are going to need to use it a lot?
ReplyDeleteI don't think this is a good idea because it gets really confusing when people delete their own comments. Sometimes, you don't even know what the comment was!
ReplyDeletePlus, YouTube is a place where people can share ideas and thoughts. People shouldn't be allowed to remove their comments.
If you're going to keep the self-comment removing, at least don't allow users to edit their comments. That would be very confusing!
ReplyDeleteLet's say someone said something good at first. And then, a person replies by saying, "Yes, I agree with you." But then, the person might just go back and edit their comment to something that is completely opposite. I hope you get my point. Don't allow self-editing!
a edit option with a time limit would have been way better, but instead this idea would break the flow of a debate.
ReplyDeletejust a couple of minutes is enough for someone to fix their typos or change and idea.
"or you simply said something you wish you could take back - now you can remove your commentary at any time."
ReplyDeleteI think its better if someone does something like that that person should reply his/her own post with something like "my previous comment does not represent my current opinion" or something like that.
<>Comment removed by user<>
ReplyDeleteI have a huge cock.
ReplyDeleteSOMPAUTA-ACTIVIDADES DE TEATRO E CIRCO-LDA CONT 508121850
ReplyDeleteBOOKING AGENCY THEATER CIRCUS COLISEU LISBOA-COLISEU OPORTO-COLISEU AZORES
PRACETA ANTONIO RIBEIRO ALVES-Nº5-7º A-2770 -016 PAÇO DE ARCOS
TEATRO:
RUA PORTAS DE SANTO ANTAO 96-1150 LISBOA-PORTUGAL
FAX COLISEU-00351-21 342 0434-MOBIL 00 351 96 648 34 04
teatrocoliseu@gmail.com
REPORT ABUSE
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RsHB05CiJqs
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wpnChH-X4b8
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=akzSL5QaSU0
Dear Sir,Director of Youtube
This videos are made without any permission or agreement.
We have this rigths( contracts with artists and broadcasting)
Please,remove because is a real abuse.
G.Herby
Great feature, spammers have been using it a lot so they can wipe clean the first couple of pages of comments, and now you can't even report them for spamming. With the comment system being broken (I'm talking about comments past page two not being in chronological order, a problem m.youtube.com doesn't seem to have for some odd reason) you can't keep track of the discussion anymore.
ReplyDeleteSorry, youtube, this "feature" simply sucks.
great!
ReplyDeleteI don't really see this feature as really necessary if people actually bothered to READ what they are planning to post instead of simply typing it all and clicking 'Post Comment' so hastily.It's actually making things alot harder.
ReplyDeleteDo yourself a favor and just take the time to read what you're about to post instead of clicking the 'Post Comment' button hastily as if you're about to die in 30 seconds.
how do i actually confirm my adress? so i can post comments?
ReplyDeleteI like it because even though I read my comments before I post, I still make spelling errors that end up messing up the whole comment. . Is it necessary to have the comment block remain and the Username present? It looks very messy like that and takes up comment space. I wouldn't mind seeing something completely removed and have it be removed, not "This comment has been deleted" Since that is something I don't need to know.
ReplyDeleteYeah cool guys, thanks, I was just thinking this morning on the way to work (yeah, I know, where is my life), "I wish I could remove my comment on YouTube".
ReplyDeleteI keep making these stupid mistakes when I write and always wanted to correct them. Great!
What next: I really think you should consider HD video or higher quality.
Also, would love to see the site with a nice Adobe-style grey background to the site!
stupid idea. you should have it where the person who owns the channel decide if they want the option of allowing people to remove their comments. this will totally ruin the flow of debate.
ReplyDeleteDespite being pretty stupid, it's probably the best update that Youtube's done in a long time.
ReplyDeleteThe people who should use this feature won't.
ReplyDeleteAbout time.
ReplyDeleteNow allow the HD player to be an option along with the 4:3 player, please.
you know, some times what the people wants might not be the best for them
ReplyDeletedoes that include comments to the youtube blog?
ReplyDeleteThanks for this feature! Came in handy...
ReplyDeleteJust after this feature came in, I wrote a comment, hit submit, didn't see it on the page, submitted it again, and then saw it twice...
So thanks to this, I was able to remove my duplicate comment
I'MMAH FIRIN' MAH LAZAR.
ReplyDeleteNew combination unlocked!!!
ReplyDelete[YouTube] + [Print Screen]
People who should use this feature, won't, and people who shouldn't use this feature, will.
ReplyDeleteA window of 30-30 minutes to delete a posted comment would by my preference if something like this must be place.
ReplyDeleteThis is an abomination. Now, people can remove comments that are against their point of views. Think of the Scientologists and conservatives deleting comments made by innocent people just trying to express themselves.
ReplyDeleteThe Youtube comment boxes allow people to debate, and you just ruined everything
"Now, people can remove comments that are against their point of views." What? Is something wrong with you? You can only delete YOUR OWN comments. (Also, nice job lumping Scientologists and conservatives together).
ReplyDeletefuck thanks alot youtube D:<
ReplyDeleteyes now i can delete my comments!
ReplyDeleteam gay and i love chris crokker!
not comments here
ReplyDeleteLOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>LOL>
ReplyDeletenice but i still don't see how to use it.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.prettymansllc.com
ReplyDelete<>Comment removed by user<>
ReplyDeleteCopy+Paste from the truest comment on here:
ReplyDelete"People who should use this feature, won't, and people who shouldn't use this feature, will. "
10 dakka susun
ReplyDeletethis feature is great! not like those stupid annotations!
ReplyDeletewait how do i use this feature?
ReplyDeletecome make money with my on my bran new system just launch 1/25.09 go see my video
ReplyDeletecome make money with my on my bran new system just launch 1/25.09 go see my video
ReplyDeleteI'm sorry, this feature is pointless. It totally debases intelligent discourse, and has lowered the standard level of accountability on chained discussions. You could have spent the time and effort developing an OPTIONAL feature (toggled by the video submitter) to allow users to edit/delete/lock comments. I could code that for a site in a couple hours.... this is terribly lazy web software development and awful site-to-end-user communication.
ReplyDeleteYou could have even developed a "Block" feature, that allows video submitters to build a list of users that are blocked from commenting on a specific video.
ReplyDeleteOr even an "ignore" feature, user(A) can comment rudely, but user(B) can gleefully ignore user(A) with ease. Each user has a list of ignored users. Comments from ignored users are hidden from the specific user that ignores them (or if added to a video's ignore list, not visible to any user). Thus, accountability and continuity of a dialog are preserved... youtube will be forward-thinking and ad-friendly.
ReplyDeleteWow, so no one needs to hold accountability anymore for their trolling or stupidity? That's great! Thanks again for another inept feature YT.
ReplyDeleteNow how do remove them exactly?
ReplyDeleteI find this very handy. Thanks, YouTube. Thanks, Google!
ReplyDeleteI really like this new feature, but I have recently noticed that you guys have removed another one: the ability to show comments with many negative votes. Now you may think that this is a harmless improvement, but I personally enjoy reading some of these. If you could bring back this feature (as well as, if not ESPECIALLY--the center frame thumbnails algorithm) I would be very grateful! Thank you for reading.
ReplyDeleteNow give us a feature where we can reupload deleted videos
ReplyDeleteAYO WHO TAUGHT U HOW TO DO DIS SHIT! DA DANCE OLD IS H3LL U R3ALLY N33D TA GO FIND DA NIGGA DAT TOLD U IT WAS NEW N FUCC HIM UP DO ME DAT FAVA BRA, ALSO U MAD3 UR SELF LOOK DUMB 4 LISTENING TO DA NIGGA BUT GO TO THIS http://vids.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=vids.individual&videoid=7315795&searchid=c275c5ad-d2f7-44fb-9fe8-c1c513e20a95 N LOOK AT DA DAT3 DO DAT 4 M3 W3 B33N DOIN THIS!!!
ReplyDeleteO Y3A L3ARN SOM3 SHIT FROM KIDS TOO LOL YOU NIGGAS BUGG3D OUT
I really can't believe this site and it's inane error messages. I c/p tags in my videos and I get this error message that I need at least one tag. If you think I'm going to type them in every time...you are crazy!
ReplyDeleteAnd you have no way to email you that is evident on the site.
ReplyDeletehi i've give an comment and want delete it but it's not working because i have wrote it wih an old deleted account
ReplyDeletewhat can i do
Relax people, YouTube is just bouncing the old-skool way. Where would the bible be without this kind of system xD... Oh, and great job with completely disabling the ability to view of spam messages. So are you guys gonna remove another portion of YT's entertainment and / or expression possibility in the near future?
ReplyDeletenice
ReplyDeleteobama
ReplyDelete--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ReplyDeleteAGRI-FARM RUSH SALE!!! AGRI-FARM RUSH SALE!!! AGRI-FARM RUSH SALE!!!
LAGUNA AREA,LILIW LAGUNA,PHILIPPINES
More than 1.2 hectares,850 - 900k negotiable.Farm planted consist mainly of 300 trees of lansones that can harvest yearly,season of september - october, also includes coconut, macapuno and santol trees, harvest on it's peak season..for more inquiries..
call/text # 09206728638 look for Ron Louie
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tQIC2KyxolU
ReplyDeleteplz delete my can from your site as some one wants to abuse me in worng way
my e mail id is jatt_friendfinder9#yahoo.co.in
my user name at you tube is gurpreetkahlon plz delete my cam as soon as u receive this my link is http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tQIC2KyxolU some one put my cam in bad sense
ReplyDeletemy yahoo id is
jatt_friendfinder9@yahoo.co.in
as some one put my cam on you tube in wrong sense plz remove it as soon as you can my email id is jatt_friendfinder9@yahoo.co.in and gurpreetsingh.kahlon@yahoo.co.in kindly reply me soon for it
ReplyDeleteBad idea You Tube
ReplyDeleteNow when you go to quote stupidity, the stupidity has been removed, and then the idiot who posted the stupidity, denies all knowledge.
A victory for the weasels.
This is a really good idea because it just gives us more control over what WE do.
ReplyDeleteThis is a test because I don't see my comments appearing.
ReplyDeleteHi there , someone have posted my video,i have not posted, in the video its me, so can you delete the video and other people do not watch, please remove it.
ReplyDeletethe link of te video is:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o7tgf-NdiwM
hmm
ReplyDeleteyeh but how do you delete your actual videos
ReplyDeleteAnd how are we supposed to find every comment we made thru the years ??? i can't search for every single one of them ! is there a list somewhere in my profile ??
ReplyDeleteincantare666, google your youtube screen name just the way you type it when signing on to youtube then hit search, everything and anything you've ever commented on will come up
ReplyDeleteHm
ReplyDeletehmmm, excellent!
ReplyDeletecool
ReplyDeletecool
ReplyDeleteHow can i put my own video??!!
ReplyDeletehow do i upload a video it keeps saying that it failed and i saved it the music video to my computer and it wont work i think i need to waite
ReplyDeletehello
ReplyDeletequit sucking Warner Bros. balls youtube!!!
ReplyDelete??????
ReplyDeletenot looking to delete but actually to go back and complile all the comments i have made - hard to work out how, can you help?
ReplyDeletehey
ReplyDeleteyoutube needs to make something to delete all the people who make hater videos about celebritys. That would be great. : ]
ReplyDeleteThank you YouTube!
ReplyDeleteI just wish you guys could do the same for channel comments, and when you delete a comment on a video, I wish it never said "Comment Removed by author" and it could just be gone forever.
sad3f32gf
ReplyDeletenn
ReplyDeleteThat tool is really helpful, although I agree with SporeDotCam. It's really, really annoying when you want to delete one of your comments and it says "Comment removed by author". Why not just introduce a tool that deletes the comments completely? You don't have to be able to "re-publish" your comments.. If that would be the case for anyone, they could just rewrite it. But besides that, thanks for a great site :)
ReplyDeleteNow make a tool where I can find all my comments throughout YT. :)
ReplyDeletepwned
ReplyDelete:)
ReplyDeleteYES BUT HOW DO I FIND THE VIDS I MADE A COMMENT YOU SMART YOUTUBE TEAM!!!!
ReplyDeleteConsidere adding "Comments I made" or something.
I agree. How can you delete a comment of your own if there is no way to search for or find the comment? GRRRRR!!!!
ReplyDeleteNo, Th3Agitator, i've just checked it out: You don't find EVERY comment you've ever made on yt via google, just some of them. Anyway, fishing for them by yourself using a search engine? You must be kidding!
ReplyDeleteThere definetely should be a PROPER function WITHIN youtube.
IT'S UP TO YOU, YOUTUBE-TEAM!!!
That would be such a big improvement especially for a high percentage typo error like me. But my "Enter" finger is always to quick to submit my posting. And "walla" too late if I can't delete or change my just posted comment.
ReplyDeleteGreat feature! Because spammers abound!
ReplyDeletehey smrtcooky98, what a you talking about? can find your coments in your account page ,no?
ReplyDelete